AMN Entertainment : : : Anime | Tek | EInsiders | Podcasts | Forums



 

Forums
Mailbag
Reviews
Previews
Media
Contact
 





Gestalt Vol. #1



Gestalt Vol. #1

Media Manga
Genre Fantasy & Action/Adventure
Publisher Viz Media
MSRP $8.99
Release Date 06/16/09
Age Rating 16+
Website Viz Media
Pages 208
ISBN 9781421526904
Layout Right-to-left

Discuss this title in the Forums

Submit your own Review


June 16, 2009

by: Serdar Yegulalp

A loopy fantasy romp from the creator of Loveless.

Manga Description: In the legendary past, the gods battled for supremacy and cast out the demon god whose name cannot be spoken. Banished to Earth, the demon found refuge on the mysterious and dangerous island known only as "G."

After experiencing a crisis of faith, Father Olivier of the Valaria Order decides to go to G and find out the truth behind the legends. Olivier's journey is unsanctioned, and the head of the Order engages the dark elf Suzu to stop him. As he begins his quest, Olivier encounters Ohri, a young girl from the south who cannot speak. As this unlikely pair travels toward their destination for very different reasons, they are shadowed not only the agents of Olivier’s order but the by the enemies from Ohri's past...

Manga Review

Content: (This section may contain spoilers.)

Here is your analogy for the day: Gestalt is like a really good hamburger. The ingredients come as no surprise, and neither is the form they come in—but is there anyone here who doesn’t like a really good hamburger? (Apologies to the vegetarians in the audience.)

The book amounts to a generic Fantasy Adventure Quest template: it not only breaks no new ground, but goes back and puts parking stripes on the old ground. And yet the whole thing is fun, in big part because of the attitude. It doesn’t take itself seriously and it doesn’t try to, either. It’s leavened with cheek and good humor, and so more than makes up for being unoriginal by having high spirits. It also sports a major selling point in that it’s an early creation from Yun Kouga, she of Loveless fame, a series I haven’t yet read but which has been next to impossible not to know about.

Gestalt takes place in a world of many lands, where the gods once all clashed with each other to see who was top dog. One of them, known only by the name “G” (much as a certain Vampire Hunter is known only by the name “D”), betrayed the others and was banished to a forbidden land by the same name. There, he languishes, and as legend has it he has the power to grant a wish to any who can find him.

Right in the first few pages of the story, we’re introduced to the man who wishes to seek G out and have his wish granted. This man isn’t some moody warrior of few words or a brash young kid with no family—instead, he’s a reticent and somewhat easily jangled priest of the Order of Valaria, Father Olivier. (Think of Abel Nightroad from Trinity Blood in his polite, oh-no-I-couldn’t-possibly-impose form.) Olivier is no complete pushover, though: he has the power of the gods at his command, to some degree. He’s just not an adventurer by nature, and so in order to fulfill this quest he’ll need a few sidekicks. He gets them, and most of them are also straight out of the traditional fantasy adventure Central Casting book: Suzu, the haughty dark elf; and Shazan, a fortune-teller with as much doom and gloom as Olivier has quiet reserve.

There’s also a fourth, and this fourth character makes this book into the romp that it is. Her name’s Ouri, a young girl whose voice has been sealed away by magic but whose irrepressible, bubbly spirits come through no matter what. She has great fun teasing Olivier even when she’s not able to speak (which leads to some of the funniest moments in the whole book). And once she does get her voice back—thanks to a battery of spells from Olivier—she really lays the teasing on thick. Her affection for him may well be genuine, but there’s plenty of reason to believe she may be headed to G for reasons of her own.

Ouri also wields magic—and no small amount of it of her own—although that allows her to make just as many bad decisions as good ones. At one point early on she’s stuck in some kind of gladiatorial game against a giant wormlike monster, and banks a little too heavily on her magic to bail her out … or maybe just the magic everyone knows about so far. And later on, her attraction to Olivier turns out to be a weakness that various newly-made enemies decide to exploit.

Art: Again, I can’t speak for how the art shapes up against Kouga’s more recent work, but it stands on its own more than decently. It has the wispy, “watery” look common to a lot of 1980s manga—a style I confess I like a great deal, especially since you don’t see very much of it even in reprints. Most of the effort in the artwork’s expended on poses and faces rather than backgrounds or action (the few action shots are essentially freeze-frame tableaux), but that kind of goes hand-in-hand with this being a more character- and quirk-centric story than a fight- and plot-centered one.

Translation: Gestalt’s been issued in the same format as the “stock” Viz editions—the $8.99-a-volume paperback-sized format for everything from Naruto to Gin Tama. The work done for this price point can be spotty: some of it’s highly complete and thought-out, some not. Gestalt is on the good side, with FX and signage retouched (albeit very cleanly) and with a nimble, readable text that doesn’t feel like a translation.

The Bottom Line: The word “romp” was coined for a book like this. The plot’s almost beside the point, and I don’t mean that as a dig at the comic. It’s that the character interactions are so free-spirited and lively, they make quibbles about plotting and logic and maybe even motivation almost irrelevant. It’s as if they all know they’re taking part in a manga, and are having a blast living up to their respective roles. All for our sakes. Ain’t that sweet of ‘em?



Content Frothy fantasy with more silliness than plot, but still fun for that reasons. 7.5

Art It's from an earlier period than the same artist's Loveless, and it shows, but it's still skillful. 7.9

Translation A solid Viz job, undistracting if also undistinguished. 8.0

Verdict

For existing Yun Kouga fans, and maybe anyone else who wants a tongue-in-cheek fantasy excursion.


7.6
[not an average]

+ Amusing character roster.
+ Yun Kouga fans will be thrilled.
- Not strong on plot.

Title Media Return to Homepage Discuss this in the Forums





Top
Previous Page
Home
News
Reviews
Previews